Insta-recipe: Heirloom Tomato Soup

by Amy on August 30, 2012

in In the Garden,In the Kitchen

A couple of days ago I made Heirloom Tomato Soup. The tomatoes are coming faster than I can eat them, and believe me, I am trying. I love to make tomato soup because it doesn’t really matter what variety you use. What made this particular batch of soup so much fun to make is that I shared step-by-step photos on as I went. I thought I would recap the recipe here, creating a more permanent, easy-to-find home for it.

Heirloom Tomato Soup


5 lbs. heirloom tomatoes, cored and cut into wedges. You can remove the skins and seeds first if you want to (a video tutorial demonstrating how to peel tomatoes can be found here), but I don’t bother because everything in the pot gets blended up nicely and I don’t like my tomato soup too thin.

1/2 cup of water

Salt, pepper and sugar, to taste

That’s it!


Place your tomato wedges in a large, heavy pot and add water. Simmer over medium heat. (And here’s where comes in…)

5 lbs. heirloom tomatoes, wedged, about to become soup. Simmer over med. heat with 1/2 cup water 15-20 minutes until softened. (to be cont'd)

The tomatoes will begin to cook down and get mushy…

About half-way cooked. Keep stirring!

…eventually turning into a slurpy, pulpy tomato slush.

Coming off the heat now to cool. See you in 15 minutes or so!

After the tomatoes have had a chance to cool for about 20-30 minutes, use an immersion hand blender to mush them all into a consistency that you like. Season to taste with salt & pepper. If the soup is too acidic, add a little sugar to taste.


Used the immersion hand blender, then added salt & pepper to taste. Add sugar I too acidic. Yum!

This soup is good hot or cold, is an excellent source of lycopene (as all cooked tomatoes are) and is, of course, completely free of preservatives, except for the little bit of salt that is added at the end. It freezes well, too. If I run out of time to eat up the rest of the tomatoes in the garden, they’re being made into soup, too!

Follow me on Twitter for more recipes this fall.